The Best Bait for a Squirrel Trap (This is ALWAYS Working!)

As a passionate nature lover with several years of experience observing and interacting with squirrels around the world, I can confidently say that peanut butter is the best bait to trap a squirrel. Its sticky texture and nutty flavor make it irresistible and more likely that the squirrel will trigger the trapping mechanism. In this blog post, I’m going to explain why you should use peanut butter as the best bait to trap a squirrel.

If you want to trap a squirrel, peanut butter is the best bait to use. Its sticky texture and nutty flavor make it irresistible to these curious rodents and they will be drawn to it quickly. Peanut butter also has the advantage of being hard for squirrels to grab quickly, forcing them to interact with the trap before they can escape. This makes it more likely that the squirrel will trigger the trapping mechanism.

  1. Peanut Butter: Nuts are a natural attractant for squirrels and peanut butter’s sticky texture & nutty flavor make it irresistible.
  2. Seeds: Sunflower seeds or other small seeds can be used as bait for squirrel traps because it is something they would naturally forage for in the wild.
  3. Fruits & Vegetables: Fruits such as apples and vegetables such as corn are additional possible baits for squirrel traps.

Best Bait to Trap a Squirrel

Peanut butter is the most effective bait to trap squirrels. Its sticky texture and nutty flavor make it irresistible to these curious rodents, and they will be drawn to it quickly. Peanut butter also has the advantage of being hard for squirrels to grab quickly, forcing them to interact with the trap before they can escape. This makes it more likely that the squirrel will trigger the trapping mechanism.

Nuts and Peanut Butter

Nuts are a natural attractant for squirrels and peanut butter’s sticky texture and nutty flavor make it even more enticing. Other nut products like almond extract can also be used to draw them in, either placed on pieces of bread or on its own.

Grains and Seeds

Squirrels also enjoy grains and seeds, such as those found in birdfeeders. Sunflower seeds or other small seeds can easily be used as bait in traps set up for these small critters.


Citrus fruits like oranges are very attractive to thirsty squirrels during hot summer days, making them an efficient bait choice by doubling the temptation. Apples are also a good option.


Even simple pieces of bread can attract squirrels towards a trap if combined with some peanut butter or nuts. Popcorn is another treat that wild squirrels love and can make a great bait when used in combination with other options.

Alternatives to Poison Baits

  • When trapping wildlife like squirrels, it’s best not to use poisonous bait as it can cause harm to them and any other animals that happen to come across it. To keep everyone safe, it’s better to use non-toxic baits instead.
  • Opt for strategic attractants: Make sure your baiting strategy takes into account what a wild animal would naturally find attractive in its environment. For instance, nuts are an advantageous enticement as they are part of their diet in nature.

Safe Handling of Trapped Animals

Safe handling of trapped animals is essential for both their welfare and your own. When handling trapped animals, be sure to wear protective gloves and use a net or large cloth to keep the animal contained. Never attempt to handle or move an animal if it’s agitated or scared – wait until it calms down before doing so. Avoid releasing the animal in an unfamiliar environment as this can be dangerous for them. Always release the animal in its natural habitat, ensuring there are no obstacles blocking their exit.

How To Place A Squirrel Trap

Choose The Right Trap For The Job

When attempting to catch a squirrel, it’s important to choose the right type of trap for the job. Box traps are ideal because they allow you to see inside of them which helps you monitor their progress without interfering with their behavior too much. Tube traps provide an extra layer of security as they require two hands to trigger the trap mechanism while snap traps tend to be harder handling and having potential safety risks involved.

Place the Trap Where You Can Check It Regularly

It is important to position your trap in an area with high squirrel activity, as this increases the chances of catching a squirrel. Be sure to place the trap on an even surface and secure it with a weight or brick to prevent the squirrel from pushing it over. Checking the trap regularly will help you assess whether or not the bait placement is effective.

Location matters when it comes to trapping squirrels: avoid placing the trap in areas that can be accessed easily by children or pets. In addition, look for shaded spots where the temperature is mild, as this can help keep them comfortable while they are in the trap.

Tips on Attic Traps

If you want to set a trap in your attic, there are certain factors that must be taken into consideration. Make sure that you place the cage away from objects and furniture, as these can interfere with the proper functioning of the device. If possible, place your trap near one of the exits used by squirrels so they are more likely to find their way inside.

In cases where multiple exits exist, install one-way traps at each entrance; these devices allow trapped animals to exit but not enter through that particular door again. Also, it’s essential to check for signs of damage and seal up any potential entry points.

Safety Precaution When Placing a Trap

Any time you use a live animal trap, you must adhere to all safety regulations outlined by your local authorities. Gloves should be worn when handling traps and bait and protective clothing may also be necessary in some cases. Avoid using poisons that may harm other animals, including pets. Traps should always be closely monitored and any non-target animals released immediately.

Note: It is advised that you contact an expert if your attempts at trapping are unsuccessful as they possess knowledge and experience regarding wildlife control methods.

What To Do With A Trapped Squirrel

Animal Relocation Methods

Once you have your live trap set up with its tasty morsel and you’ve successfully ensnared a squirrel, check your local regulations to make sure you know where to properly relocate the critter. Aim for a spot that is far enough away from your home but still close enough for it to thrive with nearby food and shelter. As you carry the cage (with the squirrel inside) towards its new home, move slowly and talk softly – this will make the animal more relaxed when released.

Where to Relocate the Animal

Once you have successfully trapped the squirrel in your property, it is important to relocate the animal swiftly, ethically, and humanely. Relocating a squirrel must be done responsibly and with consideration for its welfare; it should not be released into another area of your property. The ideal spot for relocation should be suitable habitat, with food and water sources located nearby. Make sure to release the squirrel at least five miles away from its capture location, ensuring that it has room to find new resources.

Expert Tips

Preventive Squirrel Control Techniques

  • Mop up spilled birdseed, nuts, berries and other debris; take out the trash; substitute any food squirrels don’t like for birdseed to reduce the attractants.
  • Cut back any tree limbs that are within 10 feet of the house or bird feeders. Protect any electrical lines in the vicinity by using plastic tubing as a covering. Place a chimney cap on top for extra security. And take care of any broken vents and screens, as well as any other gaps in the outer walls of the home.
  • Use a combination of methods to deter squirrels from your property. Start by applying capsaicin-based repellents, which will discourage them from the area due to their strong taste. Additionally, set up an electronic repellent to startle them and make them think twice when it comes to returning.

Common Misconceptions When Trapping Squirrels

One ofthe most common misconceptions regarding trapping squirrels is that they can avoid traps altogether; however this isn’t true as their curiosity may overpower their caution when presented with enticing baits like peanuts or peanut butter. That being said however; it’s important not to underestimate how cunning they can be – they might recognize certain smells/sounds associated with traps making them wary of approaching them too often! Therefore having strategic understanding of their behavior & applying advantageous enticements like efficient baits & successful allurements can play an important role towards setting successful traps!


What location is most conducive to trapping a squirrel?

When attempting to trap a squirrel, one should consider the best environment and location for success. Generally, areas with trees and shrubs are most effective as squirrels can climb easily among them. Placing the trap near where the squirrels have been seen eating or playing can be helpful in enticing the animal. Additionally, the placement should avoid direct sunlight and prevailing winds. Lastly, baiting the trap with seeds, nuts, fruits, corn or peanut butter can increase your chances of trapping a squirrel.

What is preventing squirrels from entering my trap?

Squirrels can be wary critters, and if they aren’t properly enticed by the bait or have a stubborn fear of the trap, it can be difficult to get them inside. Poor trapping technique with regard to placement, type of bait, timing of baiting, or any other factors might spook the squirrels and stop them from entering your trap. If you’re having trouble trapping squirrels, try making adjustments to ensure that your traps are as attractive and inviting as possible.

Can squirrels become adept at avoiding traps?

Squirrels are wary creatures, and they can be quick to take notice of their surroundings. If they encounter a trap multiple times without being captured, they will learn to avoid it. This is why it’s important to place the traps carefully and change the location each time if you don’t have success immediately.

At what time of day do you usually set traps for squirrels?

The best time to trap a squirrel is usually early in the morning or late in the evening. This is when squirrels are most active and less likely to be disturbed. Be sure to check local regulations for trapping animals, as there may be specific times that are allowed or prohibited. Place bait near the traps and check them daily.

What entices squirrels to enter a trap?

Squirrels are naturally attracted to food sources, so using the right bait is essential for trapping them. Various nuts and grains make excellent lures, as well as some fruits and vegetables. Placing the bait in an area with plenty of cover will also help attract squirrels to the trap. Additionally, setting the trap at dusk or dawn when they are more active can increase your chances of catching a squirrel.


In conclusion, peanut butter is the best bait to use to effectively trap a squirrel. Its sticky texture and nutty flavor make it irresistible and hard for them to grab quickly, making it more likely that the squirrel will trigger the trapping mechanism. In addition, other natural food items such as seeds, fruits, and vegetables can be used as an alternative bait for squirrel traps.

Overall, when you need a reliable way to trap a squirrel, peanut butter is your best bet. Its sweet aroma and desirable flavor will draw in these creatures while also providing them with a challenging task that makes it difficult for them to escape. With its effectiveness and accessibility, peanut butter is the best bait to trap a squirrel!

You may also be interested in reading: